Picture: bobvila.com
With the raft of dwelling companies digital marketplaces flooding the web, it may be tough for householders to decide on which platform to make use of when looking for contractors and professionals to finish obligatory duties. Most consumers search a good platform that may present robust references for certified professionals with as little trouble for the client as potential. HomeAdvisor and Angi (previously Angie’s Record) are two of probably the most recognizable names within the enterprise, however their affiliation with one another can additional complicate the decision-making course of for patrons: Angi and HomeAdvisor are actually each beneath the umbrella of the identical father or mother company, known as Angi, Inc. (previously ANGI Homeservices). This relationship could make it appear as if these two firms are offering the identical choices beneath two totally different names, however that’s not really the case. Every market has strengths in several areas which will make it roughly interesting to clients in several circumstances. Evaluating the 2 on the premise of chosen standards will assist make selecting the very best market for a challenge (or basic dwelling enchancment and upkeep administration) a bit simpler for householders.
Discover trusted native execs for any dwelling challenge
+
How We In contrast Dwelling Companies Web sites
Picture: istockphoto.com
- Out there companies: All on-line dwelling enchancment marketplaces promise connections with an abundance of service suppliers, however the sorts of companies offered typically differ. We in contrast the choices obtainable at HomeAdvisor vs. Angi.
- Signup and quote course of: This is likely one of the most necessary interfaces in an internet market: Most clients want to reveal as little private info as potential to achieve entry to suggestions and pricing, whereas the marketplaces need to collect as a lot info as potential for advertising and marketing campaigns. We examined the join, check in, and value estimate processes for each HomeAdvisor and Angi.
- Membership and value: Few issues are worse when procuring on-line than discovering out {that a} membership is critical to browse or store and being locked right into a contract unexpectedly. Whereas contractors ought to usually anticipate there to be some value in alternate for the promoting and enterprise that comes their approach through these marketplaces, clients rightly query the place prices are applicable and the place they don’t seem to be, and need them clearly acknowledged up entrance. We’ve thought of all the prices related to each of those firms.
- Contractor certification and licensing: What precisely constitutes a “skilled”? Platforms reminiscent of Angi and HomeAdvisor pitch contractors to clients looking for their companies, however how deeply do the businesses really vet the contractors they suggest? What sort of validation is finished to say with certainty that the contractors have the certifications and licenses they declare?
- Contractor background checks: Inviting somebody unknown into a house to do work will be intimidating for many individuals, particularly those that reside alone or have younger kids. Some clients could assume that dwelling service marketplaces have checked into the backgrounds of the contractors on their website to make sure that there’s no historical past of prison conduct, however that’s not at all times the case. In equity, intensive background checks of each individual promoting on a website can be prohibitively time consuming and costly, however the marketplaces have to be clear and up entrance about their insurance policies. We checked out each Angi’s and HomeAdvisor’s place on this.
- Buyer help: Particularly when coping with an internet service supplier, it’s necessary to know that there’s somebody to name or electronic mail if there’s an issue with the work or funds—clients have to know that somebody has their again. Each market has totally different accessibility and insurance policies relating to customer support and ensures, so we examined the extent of service obtainable at each Angi and HomeAdvisor.
HomeAdvisor vs. Angi: Execs and Cons
In some ways, HomeAdvisor and Angi are comparable companies. When the 2 firms merged beneath the Angi identify, many of the insurance policies and procedures had been standardized throughout the corporate. Nonetheless, there are nonetheless some variations which will make one or the opposite a greater match, and a few strengths and weaknesses apply to each companies.
| Execs | Cons | |
| Angi |
|
|
| HomeAdvisor |
|
|
HomeAdvisor vs. Angi: Out there Companies
What sorts of contractors can be found for rent on dwelling enchancment companies marketplaces? In all honesty, if a home-owner or renter can consider one thing they want finished, they’ll doubtless discover somebody keen and capable of do the duty (for a charge, in fact) on Angi or HomeAdvisor. In actual fact, a fast browse of the classes of accessible companies may assist generate a listing of potential tasks that the house owner didn’t even understand wanted to be finished till they found there was somebody keen to do them.
Angi boasts that it lists contractors in additional than 500 service classes, and a perusal of the search operate signifies that that is right. Angi breaks down the classes into inside companies, exterior companies, garden and backyard, and a catchall “extra” class. A number of the classes are for easy dwelling restore or renovation tasks, and sure the rationale clients come to a market to start with: home cleansing, landscaping, roof restore, rest room remodels, plumbing companies, and electrical companies. Others catch the attention of consumers who could have arrived on the website however then found further companies they want, reminiscent of childproofing, vitality audits, closet design, and basketball hoop set up.
HomeAdvisor additionally breaks its companies down into classes, however then creates even smaller subcategories. The web site is organized like a sequence of playing cards, with every card bearing a centered class title then itemizing subcategories beneath. For instance, the architects, builders, and engineers class contains hyperlinks to land surveyors, builders, allow companies, and development managers. There’s an entire class only for storage companies that might result in challenge creep and a extremely tricked-out storage when the client simply wanted a brand new door, so the centered classes could also be harmful for some. The kitchen reworking class contains hyperlinks for all the searches and companies that is likely to be wanted to finish a kitchen transform. It’s price noting that this fashion of group implies that subcategories may repeat; for example, “tile” seems within the kitchen reworking, flooring, concrete brick, and stone classes, in addition to a number of others. This isn’t an issue, but when the record of choices appears overwhelming, it’s good for householders to keep in mind that some choices are doubled up.
Verdict: Each Angi and HomeAdvisor state that they supply companies in over 500 classes, from home cleansing to full-scale reworking. Prospects will discover comparable companies on each websites.
Winner: Tie
Picture: istockphoto.com
HomeAdvisor vs. Angi: Signup and Quote Course of
One of many optimistic elements of each Angi and HomeAdvisor is that they don’t blind quote. Prospects can’t simply click on “carpet cleansing” then “3 rooms” and anticipate a suggestion and a quote that may doubtless be inaccurate as a result of the system doesn’t have sufficient info to construct a strong estimate. Alternatively, so as to present strong suggestions and create an correct quote, the major search engines want some info.
The search course of on each Angi and HomeAdvisor makes use of the identical interface—because the firms got here beneath the identical umbrella, HomeAdvisor’s tagline is “HomeAdvisor Powered By Angi,” and the search and quote course of is one space the place the method is standardized throughout each platforms. This course of guides the client by means of a sequence of click-to-answer questions that may restrict the search outcomes to contractors who specialize within the service the client is in search of. Upon clicking on a class, the person is requested for his or her ZIP code, which is sensible: Limiting the outcomes to contractors within the rapid space can slim the search and can save clients cash on journey prices and potential hauling charges. In some circumstances, the following query is whether or not or not the scenario is an emergency, and this reply could change the trajectory of the inquiry. The system then asks if the client is just budgeting or planning, after which asks about timing, whether or not the situation is a house or industrial constructing, and insurance coverage issues. It then gives a field for the client to enter some challenge particulars concerning the scope of the house enchancment challenge.
Subsequent, the search function asks for an handle and make contact with info, together with a cellphone quantity and electronic mail handle, which can trigger some clients to balk. Those that simply need to flick through native contractors earlier than choosing some from whom they want quotes could not need to enter contact info but, particularly since there’s no clear indication of the place the data goes or how it will likely be used. Moreover, there’s a launch on the underside of the cellphone and electronic mail request display that forces the client to acknowledge they’re giving the businesses and their contractors the precise to ship automated or prerecorded texts, calls, or emails. Some clients is probably not bothered by this request, however for others it is likely to be a deal-breaker, or at the least a purpose to click on off the window and take a look at one other website. There isn’t any strategy to get to the contractor listings or matches with out clearing this display. As each Angi opinions and HomeAdvisor opinions present that the businesses have reputations for extreme follow-up emails and phone calls, typically from contractors in whom the client by no means displayed curiosity, this can be a concern to think about.
The quote course of is pretty easy: The person merely enters the specified info, chooses from the matched contractors, and receives a quote or is contacted by the professional for extra particulars or an on-site estimate appointment. Each Angi and HomeAdvisor (once more by means of a standardized portal) additionally provide a fixed-price choice. Prospects can choose a job they want finished and enter the data and timeframe. Angi will choose a contractor with applicable experience and availability, and can then present a set value and choice to schedule the job. This takes the effort out of choosing a particular contractor, haggling over a value, and attempting to coordinate schedules. Many buyer reviewers on ConsumerAffairs famous how helpful they discovered the pace and effectivity of the quote and scheduling course of on-line and thru the cell apps for HomeAdvisor and Angi as effectively.
Verdict: Each Angi and HomeAdvisor require potential clients to enter their handle, challenge timeline, and make contact with info so as to discover native professionals and acquire quotes.
Winner: Tie
HomeAdvisor vs. Angi: Membership and Value
On each Angi and HomeAdvisor, costs are set by the contractors. Prospects can definitely take care of the person contractor to regulate a quoted value, however the charges that cowl an organization’s working prices are paid on the contractor’s facet of the stability sheet, not the client’s. Evaluating the quotes provided by Angi and HomeAdvisor for comparable jobs signifies that the quotes are fairly comparable throughout each platforms; the contractors know their viewers.
As famous, each marketplaces have fixed- or flat-price companies the place the client identifies the job and the timeframe, and Angi or HomeAdvisor coordinates, selects a contractor to match the worth and availability, and produces a no-haggle quote. It’s price noting that neither HomeAdvisor’s Higher Enterprise Bureau score nor Angi’s BBB score is especially robust (C+ for Angi and F for HomeAdvisor), with a good variety of complaints for each relating to billing and cancellation fees, although neither is definitely accredited by the BBB. On the upside, each firms look like fairly attentive to the complaints and try and take care of them correctly.
There’s no value to create an account at both website, which is nice as a result of there are some advantages to having an account: Account holders can hold observe of tasks, finances and plan forward, and hold funds multi functional place. Frequent customers of the companies, nevertheless, will need to take into account an Angi Key membership, which is out there at each Angi and HomeAdvisor. The membership comes at a value of $29.99 per yr. In alternate, members get 20 p.c off in sure classes of service—so long as the client makes use of one of many prepriced choices. Member-exclusive offers and promos pop up all year long. For purchasers planning a sequence of tasks, this may provide doubtlessly large financial savings. As well as, members have entry to a devoted dwelling specialist to information them by means of the method through textual content or on the app. Members can cancel at any time.
Verdict: The value a buyer pays for a service on Angi or HomeAdvisor will in the end rely on the supplier they rent and their challenge, and value ranges for prepriced companies are comparable on each websites. Angi and HomeAdvisor each provide the identical Angi Key membership, which permits clients to get 20 p.c off prepriced companies.
Winner: Tie
Picture: istockphoto.com
HomeAdvisor vs. Angi: Contractor Certification and Licensing
In most states, shoppers can test on the licensure and certification of particular person contractors through the state licensure board, both on an internet interface or by cellphone. This can be a vital step within the hiring course of, as a result of if a buyer hires an unlicensed contractor there’s no assure that allows might be cleared or householders insurance coverage will cowl any injury that ensues. It’s not OK to guess right here, and that is one space the place HomeAdvisor and Angi differ.
Angi lists the licenses and certifications that contractors present on their software to be listed on Angi. All licensing, certification, bonding, and insurance coverage info is self-reported: Angi doesn’t independently confirm that the data is, in impact, correct and sincere. The web site does present a license test device, the place clients can enter their state and click on the kind of contractor they’re hiring, after which the platform will present a hyperlink to the person state licensing board for that business to help clients in doing their very own analysis.
HomeAdvisor goes a bit additional. The corporate verifies any state-level licensing claimed by the record of firms on the location, although it doesn’t confirm native licensing. HomeAdvisor additionally verifies state enterprise filings and incorporations. This could add to a buyer’s confidence that the contractor really carries the licensing that they declare to. Nonetheless, they’ll need to keep in mind that some due diligence continues to be required and that if there’s any doubt within the buyer’s thoughts, they need to nonetheless examine through contractor opinions or impartial licensing boards as obligatory to guard themselves.
Verdict: Angi asks its contractors if they’re appropriately licensed, and all info is self-reported. HomeAdvisor goes a step additional by verifying any state-level licensing, giving clients extra peace of thoughts that service suppliers are adhering to rules.
Winner: HomeAdvisor
Discover trusted native execs for any dwelling challenge
+
HomeAdvisor vs. Angi: Contractor Background Checks
That is one other space the place clients have to be cautious about assuming that the platform is doing extra work than it’s. When hiring any contractor, clients have to perform a little analysis, utilizing on-line opinions and native social media websites, checking with the Higher Enterprise Bureau as applicable, and interviewing the precise contractor to ensure they’re snug with the individual they’re inviting into their dwelling to work. Formal background checks are too costly for most individuals to request themselves.
HomeAdvisor performs a background test on the proprietor or principal of each firm listed on its platform, excluding company accounts. Angi’s course of is comparable, although the location’s rationalization notes that it requires the background checks of featured contractors granted the Angi Licensed label or the Tremendous Service Award badge and isn’t terribly clear on whether or not or not the house owners of companies with out these designations are checked. This sounds OK—presumably a enterprise proprietor and not using a prison background isn’t going to threat their popularity by hiring staff who do have prison data—however neither platform claims to carry out background checks on each precise contractor or employee who could also be employed on its platform. These background checks are additionally restricted by particular person state restrictions, and neither firm will exclude a contractor until the background test reveals a criminal offense charged and convicted on the felony stage.
What does this imply for patrons? It implies that the background-check insurance policies at each platforms can add a measure of safety however that rigorously vetting a contractor independently continues to be extraordinarily necessary to a buyer’s security and safety.
Verdict: Angi and HomeAdvisor each carry out prison background checks on each firm proprietor (although there could also be some exception with Angi); nevertheless, the businesses can’t carry out background checks on each worker or technician which will enter a house and carry out work.
Winner: Tie
HomeAdvisor vs. Angi: Buyer Help
The father or mother firm of Angi and HomeAdvisor has labored onerous to make customer support a spotlight, so there are a number of choices when a buyer wants some assist. The customer support division is offered from the identical hub for each firms, in order that they’re one and the identical on this regard.
The customer support web page lists company contacts, media contact info, and contacts through phone, electronic mail, and the US Postal Service. Direct and rapid entry comes within the type of a toll-free phone quantity that’s widespread between each platforms. As well as, each platforms embody a well-answered FAQ web page (although lots of the solutions date again to 2021, when the businesses merged, so it’s powerful to know if the solutions are nonetheless right). A number of opinions on Trustpilot reference the superb customer support offered by HomeAdvisor when bother introduced itself. Angi’s Trustpilot opinions are a bit extra blended, with clients being both extraordinarily completely satisfied or extraordinarily sad with the client companies offered, however since each firms are serviced by one division, it seems that this can be a balanced scenario between the 2.
Verdict: Angi and HomeAdvisor share a buyer help cellphone line, so clients from both website might be accessing the identical customer support crew.
Winner: Tie
Verdict: Each HomeAdvisor and Angi are standout choices for these trying to rent professionals for a variety of dwelling companies. Relying on the client’s location, both Angi or HomeAdvisor could have extra service suppliers listed or totally different pricing.
Each Angi and HomeAdvisor provide a wealth of service suppliers for all the companies most owners and renters can think about. Whereas they’re not excellent—the shortcoming to flick through listings earlier than offering private contact info could also be a deal-breaker for some, and the persistent follow-up communications could also be a bit excessive—the very fact is that these two companies are the very best of the very best in a comparatively new business attempting to maintain up with the expertise it constructed. So how are clients to decide on? The most suitable choice is for them to go looking each and uncover which platform feels probably the most user-friendly (it might be totally different for everybody) and see which has the very best quantity of contractors of their space. The processes, customer support, and basic interface are all widespread between the 2, so clients will need to search for the variations amongst contractors by in search of a number of quotes and utilizing the free accounts at every website to maintain observe of the quotes till they’ve made the choice to maneuver ahead.
Discover trusted native execs for any dwelling challenge
+
